The 5th Circuit has resolved a coverage dispute between Murco Wall Products Inc., a Texas seller of asbestos-containing wall products in the 1970s and 1980s, and two of its excess insurers.
After the primary insurers became insolvent or exhausted their limits, the insured sought excess coverage for asbestos personal-injury claims asserted in several actions, resulting in a declaratory judgment action and two key rulings by the 5th Circuit.
The district court held that coverage was triggered at exposure to, or inhalation of, asbestos, and that the insurers’ duty to defend turned on the facts alleged in the underlying petitions. The 5th Circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part.
On the trigger issue, the court applied Texas contract-interpretation principles and affirmed that coverage is triggered by exposure. One policy defined an “occurrence” as an “accident during the policy period,” or that portion within the policy period of a continuous or repeated exposure to conditions, “which causes personal injury.” The other excess policy defined “occurrence” as “injurious exposure to conditions, which results in personal injury.”
Rejecting the insured’s argument that an occurrence requires both exposure and resulting injury, the court reasoned that personal injury is not part of the occurrence but something the occurrence causes. The court found that the language in both policies was unambiguous and enforced it as written and asbestos exposures outside the policy periods were not covered. The court declined to reach a decision regarding the insured’s continuing-injury theory, noting it had previously rejected a similar argument in Guaranty National Insurance Co. v. Azrock Industries, Inc., 211 F.3d 239 (5th Cir. 2000).
The 5th Circuit reversed the district court’s holding that the excess insurers’ duty to indemnify for defense costs was triggered by the facts alleged in the underlying complaints, not by the established facts.
Since the insurers involved were excess insurers, they did not have a direct, separate duty to defend. The insured, on its own behalf and on behalf of its insurer who funded the defense, argued that the excess policies’ definition of “ultimate net loss,” which referred to complaints “seeking such damages” required the excess insurers to indemnify it for defense costs incurred based upon the allegations in the underlying complaints, contrary to the long-standing rule regarding the duty to indemnify.
The district court agreed and read the “seeking such damages” language to find that the insurers ‘contractually’ overrode the general rule that indemnity under an insurance policy depends on established facts, effectively importing the ‘eight-corners rule’ that governs the duty to defend into the excess insurers’ duty to indemnify.
The 5th Circuit disagreed with the district court, reading that language in the context of the full insuring agreements: both policies indemnify for ultimate net loss arising from liability imposed because of a covered occurrence. The Fifth Circuit held the excess policies impose a threshold requirement for indemnity: a covered occurrence be proven before defense expenses become recoverable.