Hotel Not Liable for Celebrity’s Fall from Jacuzzi
Case Study

Hotel Not Liable for Celebrity’s Fall from Jacuzzi

January 3, 2020

After weighing the merits of a celebrity’s $850,000 slip-and-fall claim against a Syracuse-area hotel, an Onondaga jury returned a full defense verdict for Goldberg Segalla’s client.

Traveling to give a speech October 20, 2012, Jacqueline Del Rosario—also known as “America’s Marriage Coach”—checked into a hotel and proceeded to give herself a sponge bath. She claimed she had a hard time getting into the Jacuzzi in her room, however, and then allegedly fell and hurt herself trying to get out. A year later she sued the hotel, claiming the tub was improperly installed.

As her six-year legal dispute with the hotel drew to a close in December 2019, Del Rosario was demanding a settlement of $850,000.

The defense verdict signaled a decisive victory for Goldberg Segalla partner Kenneth M. Alweis, a trial attorney and key partner in Goldberg Segalla’s Retail and Hospitality practice group, among others. Alweis’s successful defense of the hotel turned primarily on the testimony of his final witness, an architect specializing in hotel design, including rooms with hot tubs and Jacuzzis. The installation of the Jacuzzi in question met manufacturer standards, the architect testified. The Onondaga  County jury agreed.


MORE ABOUT GOLDBERG SEGALLA’S RETAIL AND HOSPITALITY PRACTICE GROUP

Goldberg Segalla offers strong defense, comprehensive counsel, and long-term strategic guidance to all types of retail, hospitality, and commercial development businesses. With the knowledge and resources to handle complex litigation and arbitration and provide sound risk-avoidance counsel, Goldberg Segalla also offers clients all the benefits of a relationship with a firm that values teamwork and professionalism.