Jurisdiction: United States District Court for the District of Connecticut
On July 9, 2025, plaintiffs Michelle and Louis Tranquillo commenced a lawsuit in Connecticut Superior Court following Michelle’s mesothelioma diagnosis. Plaintiffs alleged Mrs. Tranquillo’s illness was the result of exposure to asbestos-containing products “secondarily through her husband’s employment and environmentally.”
Plaintiffs’ complaint asserted four state-law causes of action including products liability under the Connecticut Products Liability Act, recklessness, “environmental exposure,” and loss of consortium by Louis Tranquillo.
On August 20, 2025, defendant General Electric Co. removed the case to federal court. Plaintiffs tried and failed to remand the case to Connecticut Superior Court after the district court found they improperly joined defendant Met Life in an effort to defeat the rule of unanimity required for federal court jurisdiction. As a result, plaintiffs moved to dismiss the federal action without prejudice, preferring to pursue their claims in state court. GE opposed plaintiffs’ motion to dismiss with the desire to keep the case in federal court.
Pursuant to Rule 41(a)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a plaintiff may dismiss an action without a court order by either filing a notice of dismissal before the opposing party serves either an answer or a motion for summary judgment or filing a stipulation of dismissal signed by all parties who have appeared. However, precedent holds that “[v]oluntary dismissal without prejudice is…not a matter of right.” Zagano v. Fordham Univ., 900 F.2d 12, 14 (2d Cir. 1990). In determining whether a voluntary dismissal is proper, courts in this circuit employ the Zagano factors which include:
(1) the plaintiff’s diligence in bringing the motion, (2) any undue vexatiousness on the plaintiff’s part, (3) the extent to which the suit has progressed, including the defendant’s efforts and expense in preparation for trial, (4) the duplicative expenses of relitigation, and (5) the adequacy of the plaintiff’s explanations for the need to dismiss.
Zagano, 900 F.2d at 14.
In considering these factors, the court determined the first, third, fourth, and fifth factors favored dismissal. It determined plaintiffs were diligent in bringing their motion as the case was less than one year old at the time of its filing. Likewise, they moved for dismissal less than one month after the court denied their motion to remand the case to state court. Turning to the third factor, the court recognized that discovery was not to be completed until May 20, 2027, and as such, trial was still a long way off. Concerning the issue of the duplicative expenses of relitigation the court found that future expenses would not be duplicative because the case had barely been litigated at all in the first place. Finally, the court determined that plaintiffs’ perceived tactical advantage in state court was not a legitimate reason to deny their motion to dismiss. As such, the court granted plaintiffs’ motion to dismiss without prejudice and also dismissed all crossclaims between defendants as moot.